Best practices

While working on ox and integrating ox into our other open-source projects, we found a couple of patterns and best practices which might be useful for anybody starting their journey with direct style Scala and ox.

Make scopes as small as possible

If you end up using concurrency scopes such as supervised, make sure that their lifetime is as short as possible. In some cases it might be necessary to start a “global” scope (e.g. for application-wide, long-running tasks), but even if so, don’t let the global scope leak to any other parts of your code, and isolate its usage, e.g. using actors.

For all other tasks, create short-lived scopes, which handle a single request, message from a queue or a single job instance.

Integrate with callback-based APIs using channels

Callback-based APIs, including “reactive” ones, are by their nature non-structured, and don’t play well with structured concurrency. For such cases, channels are an ideal tool. Sending or receiving to/from a channel doesn’t require any context, and can be done from any thread. On the other hand, processing the data that is on the channel often involves concurrency and creating thread, which can be then done in a structured way.

Note, however, that channel operations are potentially blocking. If you can’t block, consider using a select with a default clause.

Use using Ox sparingly

Passing the Ox capability gives the method the power to start new threads - which can be a powerful tool! The goal of structured concurrency is to localise thread creation as much as possible, and disallow methods which create a thread as an effect. using Ox partially circumvents this guarantee, hence use this with caution, and pay attention not to pass it through several layers of method calls, which might make the code hard to understand.

Use mapAsView instead of map

The map and filter channel operations must be run within a concurrency scope, and perform their processing on a freshly created fork. While this still performs well, as creating virtual threads & channels is cheap, it might incur an unnecessary overhead. If the mapping/filtering logic doesn’t have effects, and isn’t blocking, it’s often sufficient to create views of channels.

In a channel view, the processing logic is run lazily, on the thread that performs the receive operation. Channel views can be created using .mapAsView, .filterAsView, and .collectAsView.